Hist 381 Kita Ikki

 

KITA IKKI

from: http://activealert.blogspot.com/2011/04/essay-lu-xun-kita-ikki-and-their.html

The longer essay is a comparison between Kita and Chinese writer Lu Xun

Early History of Kita Ikki

He was born less than 2 years after Lu Xun on Sado Island in the Sea of Japan.  He was given the name Kita Terujiro.  He later adopted the pen name Kita Ikki for his published writings.  He was educated at the prestigious Waseda University in Tokyo.

 

From 1911 to 1919 he was in China where “as an observer for the Amur River Society, he had been deeply involved in post-1911 KMT politics.  The murder of his friend, KMT master strategist Song Jiaren[27], had deeply embittered him against the Japanese government.  In his book entitled A Private History of the Chinese Revolution he blamed the government for Song’s death because it had not backed the KMT.”[28]

 

Kita modified his overall thinking during his career.  The crucial turning point was his involvement in the 1911 Chinese revolution. [29]

 

In the 1920’s Japan was dancing to a modern beat.  Strikes were common.  There were struggles between left and right.  Kita retreated to Sado Island which was his childhood home.

This was a period of naturalism and realism in Japanese literature.  Some would say that Kita was a fanatic.  He was on cocaine the last thirty years of his life.  He started as treatment for childhood eye injury.  The use of cocaine lead to visions and seeing ghosts. Kita Ikki was “a frail, one-eyed visionary, clad in a Chinese robe”.[30]

 

Kita promoted a pan-Asian movement.  He wanted Chinese to free themselves from Western domination.  The Chinese did not see the Japanese as liberators. According to his political program, a coup d'état would be necessary as to impose a more-or-less totalitarian regime based on a direct rule by the emperor so Kita would suspend the Constitution and radically reorganize the Diet to be free of any "malign influence." The new "National Reorganization Diet" would nationalize certain strategic industries, impose limits on individual wealth and private property, enact a land reform to benefit the farmers, as to strengthen Japan enable it to liberate Asia from Western imperialism.

This Kita termed the Shōwa Restoration.

 

The Writings and Influence of Kita Ikki

In Kita’s first major treatise, The Theory of National Purity and Pure Socialism, he proposed an identity between ancient political society and socialism and equated the traditional absence of private property with the diminished role of state structure.  To him the emperor symbolized the common ownership of property and hence a communal form of social existence.[31]

 

He became convinced of the importance of the imperial figure as a unifying principle of politics.  In his estimation the Chinese revolution failed precisely because of its leadership’s inability to establish a persuasive centralized political order.  …  While still in Shanghai, Kita began to draft his program for total political reorganization, in a tract called An Outline Plan for the Reorganization of the Japanese State.[32]  Originally published in 1919 and then republished in 1923, the book was heavily censored by the authorities, but clandestine uncensored copies circulated among his adherents.[33]

 

Kita Ikki had some leftist thoughts.  He believed in land reform for farmers and profit sharing with workers.  Kita was inspired by 19th century Japanese slogan: “Rich Nation Strong Military.”  Peace without war was not the way to heaven.  His book reached few people but his radical ideas spread like a slow fuse.[34]

In his Outline Plan “he advocated overthrowing the prevailing leadership in a swift and conclusive coup d’état.  By reconstituting the structure of authority, he believed, Japan would rid itself of Western political institutions and economic practices as a necessary condition for a final confrontation in Asia.”[35]

 

Underlying Kita’s writings is a sense of national crisis unleashed by capitalist and bureaucratic exploitation and leading to extreme inequality and misery in society.[36]

 

He saw the importance of the emperor not so much an institution that had survived from ancient times but as a symbol of community. … In Japan, Kita argued, the imperial institution had been preserved to represent the national culture, but its potential as a social monarchy had been suppressed by the rise of bourgeois and bureaucratic politics within the constitutional order. …. Kita was indifferent to the idea of a divine emperor.[37]

 

Kita’s theory of revolution depended on establishing the principle of a “people’s emperor” as a necessary condition for the eventual implementation of a socialist order. … The new socialist order in Japan would come without class warfare yet would include the new forces of industry and science.  A socialist revolution in Japan, moreover, would be the first step in a chain reaction leading to the liberation of all Asian countries from Western political and economic domination.[38]

 

The Japanese flag, he boasted, would one day be emblazoned on the minds of all Asian people … darkness … would be lifted in the near future when Japan engaged the West in a conclusive naval confrontation. …  Only through such an “ultimate war” would peace and power in Asia be secured.[39]

 

Once cleansed of foreign impurities, “he wrote, a revitalized Japan was destined to triumph in the cataclysm of nation-states at war.”[40]According to Kita: “after making India independent and China autonomous, the Rising Sun Flag of Japan shall offer the light of the sun to all mankind”[41]

 

The destruction of privilege, the reconstitution of community, the regulation of working conditions, such as the establishment of an eight-hour workday, equality of employment for both men and women, and numerous other proposals shaped this theory of mobilization.[42]

 

Kita advocated the total abolition of the use of Chinese ideographs.[43]  He “warned that the English language poisoned the Japanese mind and should be replaced with Esperanto.”[44] 

 

He “ended his outline with a passage from the Lotus Sutra … calling attention to the saint’s determination to lead the populace from passion and chaos to light, knowledge and salvation…. Kita no doubt saw himself as a latter-day saint in a time of grave national peril.”[45]  

 

 

Later History of Kita Ikki

While Kita himself mostly pursued a quiet, apolitical life of teaching[46] his Outline Plan became popular with young army officers.

 

They were especially attracted to some of the most incendiary aspects of his plan, which called for the replacement of the ruling elite by a coup d’état, the suspension of the Constitution, and imposition of martial law.  His ideas combined democracy, imperialism, and fascism in a self-contradictory brew that nevertheless intoxicated a growing number of the enthusiasts in the military.[47]

 

On February 26, 1936, 1400 soldiers attempted a military coup.  They assassinated some key government leaders and called on the military to rise up.  “The main object of the rebels was to wipe out the leaders of Government and the elder statesmen who advised them and the Emperor.  They would thus, they believed, create a vacuum which only the army could fill.”[48]

 

They phoned Kita to inform him.  He was stunned.[49]  Although he had been informed of the plot, Kita Ikki had no direct role in it.[50]  The impetus of the movement was the “field-grade officers, most of them sons of the soil, their heads stuffed with martial dreams of grandeur but little formal education, their political philosophy a pungent and potent admixture of National Socialism, Fascism and medieval superstition.”[51]
Emperor Hirohito was under siege.  He denounced the rebels as traitors. “’I want them crushed, not martyred,’ he said”.[52] “There would be no public trial, no fighting speeches, and definitely no martyrdom.”[53] 

The rebels were defeated but their military leaders now had an excuse to take complete control of the country.  Kita was put away, tried in a military court, and executed as a communist in 1937.    (Lu Xun’s death was just a year earlier).

 

Enshrined thereafter as a martyr, Kita’s image resurfaced in future decades in conservative Japanese literature.  Nor did his death and that of the insurrectionists slow the momentum toward a military takeover of the government: Many officers who had been sympathetic to the goals of the rebels remained in the ranks.[54]

Military control expanded.  “Asia for the Asians” became a slogan for conquest.  Kita Ikki’s ideas were used to defend an apocalyptic war.

 

 

Conclusion

Kita Ikki though was a naïve idealist who was shocked when his ideas were actually put into play.  In his imagination the image alone of the emperor and the rising sun should have been strong enough to inspire many Eastern nations to rise up and throw out Western imperialism.  He was a believer in symbols.

Bibliography

Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century: The Emergence of Modern Pacific Asia, 3rd Ed.
Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 2007.
Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century: Vol. 4 (Writers and Revolutionaries)
An documentary video series co-produced by
PBS and the Pacific Basin Institute, 1992.
Hall, John W., Marius B. Jansen, Madoka Kanah, and Denis Teitchett
The Cambridge History of Japan: Vol. 6: The Twentieth Century
Cambridge, UK: Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge, 1988.
Han Suyin  Eldest Son: Zhou Enlai and the Making of Modern China, 1898-1976
New York, NY: Hill and Wang (a division of Farrar, Straus and Giroux), 1994.
Han Suyin  The morning deluge;: Mao Tsetung and the Chinese revolution, 1893-1954
Boston, Massachusetts: Little, Brown and Company, 1972.
Lu Xun (translated with introduction and preface by William A. Lyell)
Lu Xun / Diary of a Madman and other stories
Honolulu, Hawaii: University of Hawaii Press, 1990.
Mosley, Leonard,  Hirohito / Emperor of Japan
Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1966.
Spence, Jonathan D.  The Gate of Heavenly Peace: The Chinese and Their Revolution 1895-1980
New York, NY:  The Viking Press, 1981
Totman, Conrad  A History of Japan, 2nd Ed (The Blackwell History of the World)
Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishing, 2005.

[1] Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century Vol. 4 (Writers and Revolutionaries)
[2] Han Suyin  Eldest Son  p. 13
[3] Spence, Jonathan  The Gate of Heavenly Peace p. 64 (quoting from Lu Xun’s Selected Works)
[4] Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century Vol. 4
[5] Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century Vol. 4
[6] Biographic details are from several sources especially the introduction by William Lyell to Lu Xun / Diary of a Madman and other stories
[7] Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century  p. 177 [The section on Lu Xun is a selection from Jonathan Spence, The Search for Modern China (New York: W.W. Norton, 1990)  pp. 318-319]
[8] Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century pp. 177 – 179  (quoting Spence The Search for Modern China)
[9] Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century p. 178  (quoting Spence The Search for Modern China)
[10] This paragraph and the next two were based on the video Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century Vol. 4.
Other sources give quite different dates and casualty figures.  These were confusing times.
[11] Spence, Jonathan  The Gate of Heavenly Peace  P. 241
[12] Title as translated by William Lyell and discussed in introduction to Diary of a Madman and other stories.  Others have translated the title as Call to Arms or Cry Out
[13] Spence, Jonathan  The Gate of Heavenly Peace p. 64 (quoting from Lu Xun’s Selected Works)
[14]  Spence, Jonathan  The Gate of Heavenly Peace  pp. 257 - 258
[15]  Spence, Jonathan  The Gate of Heavenly Peace  p. 288
[16] Lu Xun (translated by William Lyell) Diary of a Madman… p. 27
[17] The title is translated elsewhere as My Old Town
[18] Lu Xun (translated by William Lyell) Diary of a Madman… p. 100
[19] Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century p. 179  (quoting Jonathan Spence The Search for Modern China)
[20] Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century Vol. 4
[21] According to an article at the Encarta Encyclopaedia:
Ding Ling (1904–1986) was assumed name of Chinese novelist Chiang Wei-Chih.
She was persecuted by both the KMT in the thirties and the communists in the fifties.
[22] Spence, Jonathan  The Gate of Heavenly Peace p. 288 (quoting from Hsia Tsi-an’s The Gate of Darkness, Studies on a the Leftist Literary Movement in China. Seattle, 1968)
[23] Spence, Jonathan The Gate of Heavenly Peace p. 293 (quoting from Bonnie S. McDougall’s Mao Zedong’s “Talks at the Yan’an Conference on Literature and Art”. Ann Arbour, 1980)
[24] Han Suyin  The Morning Deluge  p. 353
[25] Spence, Jonathan The Gate of Heavenly Peace p. 360
[26] Introduction by William Lyell to Diary of a Madman and other stories  p. xxx
[27] According to an article at the Encarta Encyclopaedia:
Song Jiaren (1882-1913) was a Chinese political leader and advocate of democracy in China.  In 1904 Song fled to Japan where he studied law at Waseda University – which is where he probably met fellow Waseda student Kita Ikki.  Song was a founding member of the Tongmenghui (Revolutionary Alliance).   He returned to China in 1910.  The Tongmenghui and several smaller political parties merged to form the KMT. Song’s energetic campaigning won the KMT a majority of seats in 1912 elections, but his speeches angered President Yuan Shikai.  Song was assassinated in March 1913 at the Shanghai Railway Station.
[28] Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century p. 197
[29] This and the next four paragraphs were based on Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century Vol. 4
[30] quote from Totman, Conrad  The History of Japan p. 378
[31] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan p. 717
[32] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan p. 718
[33] Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century p. 197
[34] This paragraph is based upon Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century Vol. 4
[35] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan  p. 719
[36] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan  p. 718
[37] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan  p. 719
[38] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan  p. 720
[39] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan  p. 721
[40] Totman, Conrad  The History of Japan p. 378
[41] Quote is from George M. Wilson Radical Nationalism in Japan: Kita Ikki 1883 – 1937  (Cambridge, MA HUP, 1969) as mention in The History of Japan (Totman, Conrad  p. 378)
[42] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan  p. 721
[43] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan  p. 721
[44] Totman, Conrad  The History of Japan  p. 378
[45] Hall, John  The Cambridge History of Japan  pp. 721 – 722.
[46] Totman, Conrad  The History of Japan  p. 378
[47] Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century  p. 198
[48] Mosley, Leonard,  Hirohito  p. 140
[49] Gibney, Alex  The Pacific Century: Vol. 4 [video]
[50] Borthwick, Mark  Pacific Century p. 199
[51] Mosley, Leonard,  Hirohito  p. 133
[52] Mosley, Leonard,  Hirohito  p. 145
[53] Mosley, Leonard,  Hirohito  p. 146